Friday, February 29, 2008
If Every Day were a Leap Day
Back in January, the WSJ had an article about how builders are reducing the choices available to new home buyers as a way to cut their costs. Apparently builders have finally figured out, the more you build to suit your buyer, the more your operating costs go up (or perhaps they just didn’t care during the boom times).
A perfect example of this trend can be seen at Lennar’s Blackstone El Dorado development. There, all the homes come with standard upgrades. The only customization allowed is in the flooring. This lack of choice was very surprising to us as buyers, since this is a rather high end development.
It also seems somewhat counterintuitive to me. As buyers have more to choose from these days, they are likely to be more discerning and want something suited to their tastes (as opposed to the time, when buyers were just grateful to get on the list to purchase a new home). I guess that’s why many builders are offering so many incentives, to differentiate themselves. However Lennar has built themselves into a corner regarding Blackstone (pun intended =). They already include all the trendy upgrades, so there isn’t much else they can do to tempt prospective buyers. I believe this commoditization of homes (no matter how nice) will lead to some depreciation for the new owners, because when the development is completed, the re-sales will have to compete almost purely on price and lot size/location.
Many of the major builders use the same floor plans from one development to the next, so commoditization is already a big problem in the rest of Sacramento. There are just too many similar homes on the market (Elk Grove, Natomas, Anatolia, Serrano etc.). The main way to make your home stand out, price it below your competition!
This scarcity argument has been used by many to explain why East Sac and other locations around town have not lost as much value compared to locations like Elk Grove. East Sac homes are both unique in character, supply (they come on the market less frequently), as well as location (close to the city) so there should definitely be a price premium that comes with these home. Just how much is a subject of great controversy =)
Thursday, February 28, 2008
Breaking Even
I assumed a $350,000 principle and then incremented the interest rate by 1/8 to get a payment schedule. I then took that payment schedule and assumed a fixed rate of 6.5% to get a corresponding principle.
This helped me arrive at a general relationship between interest rates and price drops. With my assumptions, for every 1/8 interest rates rise, you would need a 1.4-1.6% decrease in price to still break even.
To put it in easy to remember terms, for every 1% increase in rates, you need a corresponding 11-12% decrease in price to still break even (the relationship is close to linear, but not quite, for the interest rates I looked at).
Of course I would rather have a lower principle and higher interest rate, for all the reasons pointed out yesterday......but in the end, you still have to come up with the cash each month.
I'm sure there is some elegant interactive calculator for this type of analysis. If anyone knows of one, please let me know the URL so I can post it on the sidebar.
Wednesday, February 27, 2008
What a Fine Mess We are In
My mom, who retires this month, sold her home in late 2006. She has become much more serious about getting back into the market lately, since her options for a reasonable return on her financial assets (i.e. cash from selling her home) have dwindled significantly with all the rate cuts.
While her situation is slightly different than mine, recent news about increased inflation risks also has me wondering if it might be better to purchase sooner than later, even though the housing market hasn’t reached bottom yet. I do think the Sacramento housing market will be one of the first to stabilize…..since it was also one of the first to crack. I also believe, with the recent acceleration in price drops, that we will see begin to see signs of stabilization sooner than some had predicted.
Much of my increased confusion comes from trying to weigh the uncertainty and risks involved on either side.
If inflation is going to strengthen to the point where it will overshadow the remaining reductions in the housing market, the time to buy is sooner, while rates are still relatively low (before the Fed raises rates to contain it).
If the economy cools, the credit crunch continues to deepen, and inflation is contained, it could cause the housing market to overcorrect, in which case it would be best to wait.
And of course, there is the dreaded third scenario, stagflation, which I have no idea how to handle.
It all seems so incredibly complex. I doubt many average buyers, like myself ,will be able to successfully navigate (after all, even the experts seem to be getting it wrong on a regular basis).
What I often wonder as of late, has always been this way, and I just wasn’t paying enough attention ……or are we really at a critical crossroad?
Still in the Running
Currently the numbers stand at:
Inventory: 15,221
Duncan is looking like the favorite right now on inventory (Sacramentia is close numerically, but I don't think inventory has ever cratered in spring).
Median Price: $315,000
Cymst and I are out of the running on median price. And at the rate things are going, its anyones game. In 5 weeks, its fallen almost 10k!
In case you missed it, here are the details of the get together.
Tuesday, February 26, 2008
Getting Personal
During escrow on our first home, we were on rather nice terms with the seller. It was great because she introduced us to some of the neighbors, and gave us a little insight into the home and neighborhood.
In the past, my husband has suggested skirting a seller’s agent and contacting the seller directly to make negotiating easier in some circumstances (this was also before we had an agent).
Last night it came to light that a mom I know, and called to get her thoughts on transaction, actually knows the owner of the home we made an offer on.
So my question is this, what are the pros and cons of talking directly to the seller of a home (in the different stages of the negotiations)?
In some situations I can see how it would actually help with negotiations (the agent representing the buyer of our D.C. home was a first class jerk and we came very close to killing the deal during the inspection process as a result). But in others I would imagine its best to go though an agent.
Sunday, February 24, 2008
Blog Admin - Comment Policy
Good Intentions with Unfortunate Results
While some bubble bloggers might be filled with glee about this news, its quite the opposite for me.
Many of these moms in this group had bought homes in the last 5 years......not because they were looking to make a quick buck in the market, but because they wanted to settle down and raise their kids in a relatively safe neighborhood.
With two young children I am exposed to this particular demographic on a regular basis. For it is my generation and the one right below me that will pay a disproportionate price for all the irrational exuberance that occurred in the last 6 years (for example, my little brother is close to a negative equity situation down in Orange County.....they bought a home, were married and had a baby in the last 4 years).
While I am not the type of person to wish ill on others, I can't help but feel angry at those responsible for the fraud and speculation that fed this housing bubble. Many average families will be under a lot of financial stress, merely because their biological clocks were ticking at a very inopportune time. It all seems so unfair.
Friday, February 22, 2008
Do I Still Need the Approval of Others?
The agent is now asking for a preapproval letter.
I can see how preapproval was a “must have” during the boom, when multiple offers were rolling in, because it hedged sellers from wasting their time accepting offers that were not realistic.
But now that the RE heyday is over……and offers are few and far between (this home has been on the market well over 100 days), can a pre-approval really make a difference?
Our offer, which was about 15% below asking, if accepted, would mean a short sale. Now if they really don’t have any intention of accepting our offer, why the heck does the agent need a preapproval letter?
Personally I don’t like the idea of getting pre-approved with each offer because it means my credit will be checked (my old letter is from June of 2007). Each time my credit is checked, it means my score will take a hit. Given that this is likely to be a long process (finding a home someone is willing to sell at a price I am willing to offer), I don’t want to hit my credit each time I make an offer because it could bring down my credit score and eventually affect my rate when I really do go to apply for a loan. I don't want to provide a blanket amount either, cause then the seller will know how much wiggle room we have (our not so current letter is for 8% more than our offer).
The RE industry seems to be dominated by dogma, so much so, that no one really stops to question why its being done that way in the first place. Pre approval letters benefited sellers when they had the upper hand. But now that buyers have the upper hand, I think they should be able to dictate the terms.
Thursday, February 21, 2008
Without Rain...
I don't remember seeing rainbows when I lived in Sacramento near Sac State (and one of those years it flooded due to excessive rain).
There must be something particular to the foothills where I live.......because we regularly have the pleasure of big beautiful rainbows that arch across the entire sky.
Today, I was treated to one below when I went to get my mail.
Folsom and El Dorado Hills Historical Trends up to January 2008
For a nice write up on the pros and cons of different price indices at Calculated Risk. I agree with their explanation and think it applies to the real estate trends and statistics we have seen for El Dorado Hills and Folsom:
"The NAR, DataQuick and other reports use the median house price; they take all the recent sales, and find the median price. This can be distorted by the mix of homes sold. When the bubble first burst, the median price continued to rise because fewer lower end houses were sold (the low end portion of the market with subprime loans slowed first). Now with jumbos being limited, the high end sales volume has fallen, and the median price has fallen quickly."
I especially agree with some of the concluding remarks:
"However I believe prices will fall across the board, and that the subprime market was just the first segment to see price declines."
Wednesday, February 20, 2008
Does Bad Juju Scare You?
Last Sunday we looked at several homes. One of them, and REO on 5 acres in Shingle Springs, had a very odd room (labeled “photo room” in the breaker box). So of course my imagination got the better of me, and I got a little creeped out by the potential activities that took place there (out of earshot of even the closest neighbors). While the price was very good for the location and condition of the house…..I was a bit leary due to the potential bad vibes of the house.
This isn’t the first time bad vibes have made me rule out a home. Last spring we had driven by a house listed for sale on Tam O’Shanter in EDH, and I got the willies just driving by it. Something was amiss. Can’t say what it was.....it felt haunted...in a bad way. And was certainly enough for me to cross it off my list (and it was a much shorter list back then).
Another mom I know was considering purchasing a home in Stonbriar a while back. Apparently a man had killed his wife there, but she was okay with it. Personally, I’m not sure I could live in a house where I knew something like that happened.
So for everyone who is purchasing a house to actually live in…..does bad juju influence your purchase decision? I am not sure if there is a price point at which I would consider a home with bad juju, assuming we planned to actually live there.
Monday, February 18, 2008
Sign of the Times
This evening, only 6 products came up! I had to double check my criteria to make sure I didn't hit some weird option on accident. But it was no mistake....in fact other loan types had even fewer products.
The screws are seriously tightening......
One's Lot in Life
Now that the boom has ended, the truth comes out. No one really wanted these homes, at least not at current prices. They only sold, because it was all people could afford. If they had a choice, as buyers do now, they wouldn’t purchase a home with a lot so small and a house so tall, that no sun will shine between you and your neighbors except at midday.
Downtown living is different of course. There, small lots allow for walk-ability, and the houses, for the most part, are charming. In the suburbs, all the houses tend to look alike, and very few people walk or bike to the grocery store anymore (not including Davis). So if you are going to bother living in the burbs, why wouldn’t you want a larger lot?….isn’t that the point, to find more elbow room than you would in the city?
The trend is that people would rather have a large lot, and a less grandiose home, as opposed to the other way around. Of course we fall into this bucket, so perhaps it’s my personal bias interpreting comments made by others.
We checked out several homes this weekend, all with above average lot size. I didn’t really fall in love with any of them….but I am not sure how much longer I will be able to hold out.
Saturday, February 16, 2008
January/February Month's Inventory
Low sales numbers appear to be driving data, however as many have noted, inventory is also unusually high for this time of year. I expect sales numbers to pick up next month due to rate driven activity.
I also expect that some of the more iron clad zips will start to deteriorate at a faster pace now (including the ones I watch, 95762, 95630) as demand is siphoned by off to other areas which have become more affordable in the last year or so.
SFH inventory was collected from Zip Realty, and January SFH sales are from DataQuick via the SacBee.
Friday, February 15, 2008
Prime CA Real Estate for $20 a Night
This situation is a great example of a deliberate market failure. It is deliberate because the government does not charge a market clearing price on purpose. We as a nation choose not to charge market value for Yosemite campsites because we want to guarantee access to all Americans and Foreign Tourists. Thus there is a deluge of demand for a limited supply. So in this situation the government relies on a first come, first served system instead. Unfortunately there is a great deal of gaming that can occur in this situation, and it doesn't necessarily result in an equitable allocation. Of course I am grateful for this alternative allocation policy, as we at least have a shot at securing campsites this way.
This situation also has much in common with the one I often study, landing slots at busy airports, which are also allocated on a first come, first served basis.....in aviation, when a resource is underpriced, the price is paid in time and not $$....hence all the delay as aircraft are forced to wait their turn.
Feb Inventory Update
While gathering the data noticed that EDH, even though up this month, has really dropped overall. Some have pointed this out in the comments as a sign of recovery......yet the month's inventory has remained relatively high due to low sales numbers which seems to cancel this effect out. Anyways, I haven't seen the drop reflected it in my personal searches because a much larger portion of the available inventory is now within my price range.
As far as Sacramento Metro asking price distributions.....I changed the graph so it is a bit more intuitive to look at. Now the area under the curve represents the percent of homes available in a given price range. So as the market returns to affordability, we should see the graph bulge out on the left hand side over time. I was rather surprised at how quickly this movement has taken place. In just one month there are very noticeable changes.
Thursday, February 14, 2008
Whoo hoo!!! $1,200!
For the life of me, I can’t understand how Mrs. Paul thinks. She said our three car garage is already filled with so much stuff we can’t even walk through it, let alone park a car in it, so she says we should just use the $1,200 to pay off some of our credit card debt and not buy anything else. So ... trying to explain it as simply as I could for her ... I told that is exactly what we are going to do when we get the money next summer .... use it to pay for the things that we buy today! But right now there are things that I need and I deserve and I want. (Anyway, we have to hurry and use what’s left of our credit card limits soon because I’m pretty sure the banks are going to cancel our credit cards as soon as they learn we haven’t made any payments on our house for nine months.)
Then she started talking this nonsense about using the money to help America’s economy and how if we shop at WalMart, we only help China’s economy. How much more American can it be to buy from WalMart, founded by the greatest American ever, Sam Walton? I'm not sure I convinced her completely because she just kept saying, “我可爱的傻老公,他什么时候能学聪明点啊?” whatever that means.
So anyway, that is our plan for today.
The only part I’m still trying to figure out is ... if its so great for the economy when the government gives us our $1,200 back, then how much better would the economy be if the government gave us all of our money back?
Wednesday, February 13, 2008
What's our Price Range?
In theory we could stretch temporarily by paying less into our 401k. This would then be offset in a few years once we aren’t paying for daycare (approximately $1,800 a month). We are interested in finding a home where we can raise the kids and grow old (hence the interest in a single story), so stretching a bit now to make sure it meets our future needs is a big consideration.
We have swung wildly in both directions. In the past we have seriously considered houses with some land, and/or other special features and been willing to spend up to 30% above my desired budget. Other times I think it might be better to purchase a home we could afford on just one salary, to allow us a greater financial safety net (job loss, or stay at home mom/dad).
Over the last 6 months, my range has slowly evolved downward with the home and credit markets. Last year at this time we were looking at higher price ranges. However we didn’t quite have the 20% down for that range. So now with the credit tightening issues, and plentiful home choices, I have lowered my comfort range to the 20% mark.
All this to say, nothing is set in stone for us. Perhaps I am being a typical indecisive woman. But I also think it’s important to continually reevaluate one’s situation based on new information.
(And yes daycare really is that expensive.....if you think about it, its only around 5.50 an hour per kid....why college tuition gets all the press and special perks is beyond me.)
Tuesday, February 12, 2008
That Sentimental Feeling
There are many in the RE industry that mistakenly believe they merely have a PR problem on their hands (and not a speculative bubble). In other words, some have been quoted saying that the negative press has soured buyer sentiment. They have theorized that their problems would be solved if the media would just be a little more upbeat about things (and many have written positive spin pieces with that in mind….I find the latest NAR campaign absolutely nauseating).
If you are buying a home to live in, as opposed to an investment, is sentiment really driving your purchase? Back in the “priced out forever days” I can see how sentiment was a factor. But now that the market has cooled and prices have dropped a bit, the artificial sense of urgency has evaporated.
Ironically, now that there are plenty of homes in my price range, I feel even more compelled to wait, since I am assured that something reasonable is out there if I needed to purchase immediately (as opposed to last year at this time when there were only a handful of homes at or below my range).
I think sentiment comes into play in the decision to look or list a home. But sentiment will not save this market because it cannot actually purchase a home. Without access to piggyback, no-doc, ARM, or interest only loans, the spirit may be willing, but the financing gods may not be (although there does seem to be a lot of anecdotal stories to the contrary). And who actually has 20% down these days unless they have come from the Bay Area?
For the financially disciplined who actually have the 20% and the access to credit, their hearts and minds are not as likely to be swayed by NAR ad campaigns and Realtor spin.
A campaign to win back buyer sentiment?
So over the last 3-4 months I have started to wonder if members of the REIC (especially NAR operatives) have been posting on some of the RE blogs in an attempt to try and turn around buyer sentiment. While this might sound a bit far fetched, I think it would be a perfectly logical action to take if someone thought they had a buyer sentiment problem.
BT on conspiracy theories
I happen to love conspiracy theories. For instance I am still holding out hope that we will find out who really killed JFK and why, since very few can resist a death bed confession/memoire. The mastermind behind it should be getting up there in years right about now.
Monday, February 11, 2008
Losing Perspective
One result is that when I visit places I have been to before, I notice all the for sale signs now. I'm not sure if they were there before and I just didn't notice, or if there really are more signs and lots of empty commercial space. This past week was no exception.
We went on an actual vacation to Maui this last week as part of a family reunion. The Hawaiian Islands are home to some of the nation's most expensive RE....but there seemed to be for sale signs everywhere. Could it be that people are trying to offload expensive vacation homes? Or is it just the norm for that location and this time of year?
I feel I have lost my sense of perspective on what is a normal level of activity.
Saturday, February 9, 2008
Getting rich flipping houses
Tonight, I saw a first for me. At the beginning of the show was a warning: "These are real people investing real money. You can lose money flipping houses." (Or words to that effect. The show was "Flip That House.")
I recently predicted to a friend of mine, only a little in jest, that with the slowdown in subdivisions being built, the construction defect attorneys will be out of work soon and likely shift their focus from suing developers and builders to suing real estate agents, appraisers and lenders, for not adequately warning purchasers that they could lose money buying a house.
Friday, February 8, 2008
Flipping in Cameron Park
Moral Hazard
When people buy homes and borrow the money to buy the home, they sign a promissory note. A promissory note is (or at least used to be) a legally binding contract between the borrower and the lender. The lender, in consideration of the interest it was to receive, promised the borrower to loan the money. The borrower, in turn, promised the lender that it would repay the lender pursuant to the terms and conditions of the promissory note.
In the past few years, lots of borrowers signed promissory notes with ARM’s. In the past three months, various politicians have been on their soap boxes pressuring the lenders to basically forget the written contracts with the borrowers, and freeze mortgage interest rates. At least one presidential candidate is apparently talking about a government mandated freeze on ARM interest rates for 5 years, and a moratorium on foreclosures. In other words, the government is telling the world that those contracts don’t really mean anything anymore.
So if the government is telling everyone that the borrowers’ contracts don’t mean anything any more, is it any wonder that it has become socially acceptable to “walk” on a real estate loan that has lost its appeal in an environment of declining real estate prices?
And if the government actually freezes interest rates on existing ARM’s (in contrast to its “encouraging” investors to freeze interest rates), is that a taking of a private property right requiring the government to pay the investor for the lost of interest? In other words, a government (read: taxpayer) paid bailout of borrowers?
Thursday, February 7, 2008
Hubris ...
So I return to fundamentals. If the fundamentals suggest to me that the bulk of the price declines are behind us, I’ll start making offers. And I will continue to watch local inventories, average home prices, average days on market, price/square foot and any other meaningful evidence that is out there, to try to gauge when that time has arrived, rather than foolishly wait (perhaps forever) for my “guess” as to where home prices are going to go, to come true. And maybe despite evidence that prices are still declining, if the “perfect” property at the right price comes in my morning real estate email, I’ll still make an offer.
Wednesday, February 6, 2008
What inning are we in?
So my questions are: What inning do you think we are in now? While no one can know where we are headed in terms of real estate prices, what is your guess as to what statistical measure is most predictive of where prices will bottom? Or is the worst over with the Feds attempts to flood the market with cheap money? Or will politicians freeze resets for 5 years (more on this tomorrow) and save the day?
Monday, February 4, 2008
Where will the home buyers come from?
As for move up buyers, until they can sell their homes (frequently entry level homes) to someone, they are not likely to be a significant percentage of new buyers. And depending upon when/where “the bottom” is, many folks who may not lose their homes to foreclosure, are still likely to have negative equity for years to come.
I have read some reports suggesting that as a result of demographic and culture changes, new household formations are not as robust as recent years. Specifically, one report stated that young males and females are devoting more time to college and career planning, and delaying relationships and new household formations.
I have read anecdotal reports that investor purchases represented 50% of the2007 home sales in Sacramento. I do not know how deep those investors pockets are (to keep buying up inventory), but I expect most of their purchase will be limited to entry level and lower priced homes. And if prices continue to drop, the homes the investors purchased in 2007 are likely to decline in value potentially discouraging the investors from more purchases. (Contrarians would say that we will only reach "the bottom" when all of the investors "capitulate.")
As to immigration, we are only likely to see immigration if we have plenty of good paying jobs to offer. The labor department reports a decline of 9,000 jobs in the Sacramento region over the last 6 months of 2007, and an increase in the unemployment rate from 5.4% to 5.9%. (I think many people underestimate the significance of a 10% increase in the unemployment rate in only 6 months time.) I suspect that due to declining property and sales tax revenue, we will see a measurable decline in local government employment over the next year or two. (I recently quizzed the staff in one Bay Area city. I was told that this particular city is looking at 8% budget declines this year, and “guessing” at 10% budget declines next year.)
Additionally, I think it is reasonable to conclude that lenders will be very slow to return to offering subprime mortgages. This suggests to me that all of the millions of families (nationwide) who have lost or are likely to lose their homes to foreclosure, will have credit ratings that will negatively impair their ability to re-enter the home ownership market. And if lenders actually require buyers to make a down payment (What is this world coming too? A down payment?), this is likely to further reduce the number of potential buyers.
Those of us who fall into the “happy renter” category are ready to pounce when the prices appear to be near a bottom, but statistically, I don’t think there are enough of us to turn the market around.
Where do you think “new” buyers will come from for us to have a turn around in the local real estate market?
Sunday, February 3, 2008
What’s going on out there?
I had an interest in the house because I liked the location, so when the notice of default showed up on the foreclosures last year, I started monitoring it. The bank finally took the property back in December 2007, and listed it for under $400k. Still having an interest in the property, but not wanting to appear anxious before I submitted an offer based on my guess as to where I thought the “bottom” might be in a year or two, I waited until the property had been on the market for over a month. When I saw an article in the Wall Street Journal about the lending bank’s earnings declining 98%, I thought maybe it would be a good time to make an offer on the house with a quick close date. So I called my friendly real estate agent (she has been my agent for 18 years and we have become friends). I asked her to do some preliminary research. Specifically, review the listing history, call the prior and current listing agents and ask about disclosures and problems with the house, as well as availability.
Here is what she reported to me later that day: An initial offer was accepted and the property went pending. But FHA wouldn’t insure it, so the buyer cancelled. There were two new offers pending, and a third on the way, according to the listing agent.
Most interesting to me: There was pending litigation between the 2005 buyer and prior seller over roof leaks and mold.
So my wonderful agent knows me, and she knew I would run, not walk, from a house with mold litigation and stigma, so she wasn’t surprised when I thanked her for her time and offered to buy her lunch while we waited for the next house to come along.
And it got me to thinking. With such a massive inventory of homes out there, who would buy a house with mold problems, unless the price was significantly discounted? Who would get into a bidding war over such a house? It's not that great of a house or location. And even then, could they ever get homeowner’s insurance for the house? (The insurance companies maintain and share a database of properties with prior mold claims.)
Saturday, February 2, 2008
Is it just me, or ... ?
From today’s (and recent days) Wall Street Journal: The rating agencies (S&P, Fitch, etc.) rated some of the subprime, Alt-A and prime mortgage backed investments, as “AAA” investments, the highest possible rating. Monoline insurers like Ambac and MBIA, wrote insurance policies guaranteeing the credit quality of some of the mortgage backed investments. The rating agencies, in turn, gave “AAA” ratings to the monoline insurers. With AAA ratings on both the underlying investments and the insurance companies, investors all over the world (Citibank, UBS, Deutsche Bank, Bank of China, Sumitomo Bank, etc.) bought the mortgage backed investments.
As we all know now, Murphy’s Law prevailed over the mighty computer models of Wall Street, and mortgage backed investments have tanked. So, somewhat belatedly, the rating agencies are lowering the ratings of many of those mortgage backed investments. Each time a bank’s mortgage backed investment receives a lower rating, the bank would normally reduce the value of the investment on the bank’s books. Thus, the massive write-downs we have seen recently on Wall Street. This has also increased the exposure of the monoline insurers to potential claims, and the rating agencies are lowering the ratings of the insurers (or threatening to).
Now, to prevent another $70 billion in bank write-downs that might arise if the rating agencies lower the ratings on the monoline insurers, the banks are working on a bailout plan (the banks call it “recapitalization”) of the monoline insurers. One of the tentative plans is for the banks to invest about $1 billion in MBIA to increase its capital. So in other words, the banks are investing $1 billion in the monoline insurers to prop them up so that S&P doesn’t lower the insurers’ ratings and the banks don’t have to take $70 billion more write-downs.
Now, from the banks perspective, investing $1 billion to save $70 billion is cheap insurance, but if the mortgage backed investments are really worth $70 billion less (without AAA insurance), how is an extra $1 billion of insurance going to really make a difference against $70 billion in claims? I’m just an average guy on the street and this doesn’t pass the smell test for me, yet it appears that the SEC and Federal Reserve are okay with it.
Friday, February 1, 2008
Housekeeping
February 2008 Good Buys & Offers
On a personal note, I have been seeing many more "reasonable" buys lately....but we try not to drag our Realtor out for a showing unless Mr. BT & I are willing to put in an offer. So I don't have a lot of intel on properties lately (just the occasional open house). Which means most of my assessments are based on the data I find online and some drive bys.
Pieces of data to include: Zip Code, MLS or Development Name, List Price, Incentives, Offer (if any), house details (sq ft, garage size, lots size etc).
Feel free to post info for homes anywhere in the Sacramento Metro area. Just cause I tend to confine my search to the Gold River, Folsom, El Dorado Hills, Cameron Park areas doesn't mean others have to.
Thursday, January 31, 2008
The Weekly Screen Scrape - What Goes Up.....
Some interesting price trends.....there are now 19 homes over 2000 sqft priced at or below $400k. Almost half are pending. There are 26 homes at or below $175 a square foot, and almost half of those are pending as well. For a bit of comparison, of all 137 homes, only around 25% are pending.
To pull the trigger on one of these homes I am looking have my fully loaded monthly rent vs. buy calcs within +/- 10%, as well as come within a reasonable range on the inflation adjusted price (from '00 or '01) +/- $20k ........and of course a seller to accept that offer. In other words, first I am looking to figure if the transaction makes financial sense for us, and second, we want to be reasonably heged against further drops in price. I really want to purchase before my oldest starts kindergarten....which means close to bottom will have to be good enough for us.
Wednesday, January 30, 2008
With Each New Day, A New Story
He had like 6 calls in the first 5 minutes of showing up (and boy was he late...but I work at home so its not as aggravating). I overheard him say on the 4th or so call that he can't work late cause he is meeting his Realtor tonight. I couldn't help myself...and had to ask if he was buying or selling. His response, "I'm one of the subprime folks".
He and his wife bought a home for a price that automatically gave them $60k in equity according to the appraisal in 04 or 05 (can't remember exactly), but now it is worth less than he paid. Interest only loan, and about to adjust. Sounds like they will be moving to somewhere in TX where they can get more home for half what they paid here. He said his payment is $3000 a month. Yikes (waaay more than our rent).
I didn't get many details since he kept getting phone calls and I didn't want to pry.
Have I mentioned how much I like our landlord? Really nice guy, and got right on the dishwasher thing!
Tuesday, January 29, 2008
Civic Duty Reminder
If you don't participate in the democratic process, you have no right to complain about the results (opting out is a copout).
I love the mail ballot option in El Dorado County. I also love being back in California because they actually send you information on what you are being asked to vote on.
Sacramento Settlement Patterns and the Desirability Debate
I asked for something to back up this claim, because based on my knowledge of historical settlement patterns, the opposite seemed true. (Granted I am making some sweeping generalizations here with no research to back it up….so feel free to take a shot at me.)
Let me explain. In my field (aviation), supply tends to be a reflection of demand. For example, airline schedules tend to reflect passengers ‘desirability” (frequent flights between desired destinations and lots of flights in the morning and late afternoon to accommodate business schedules).
Now let’s apply this same logic to settlement patterns in the Sacramento Metro area. Initially I believe settlement patterns, and hence desirability, was based on 2 major factors. The first was access to a source of water, which our rivers provide. The second was transportation networks; originally the rivers, and later rail and major highways. These two factors appear to be fairly universal; hence most of the world’s major cities are located on major rivers, and coastal areas. Historically hill settlements tended to be the exception, only when no flat lands were available, or because of defense needs (easy to see the enemy coming).
Fast forward a hundred years or so, and many of the most desirable flat lands have been settled. Thus building began in less desirable suburban locations. However, the less desirable locations were often balanced out by the fact that the suburbs were newer, and the infrastructure in parts of city centers was starting to decay.
In Sacramento this phenomena seems a bit more dynamic because flood risk added additional criteria to the desirability. However, contrary to the belief of some, the entire Sac Metro area is not in danger of flooding. There are many respectable neighborhoods, not in the hills, that have a minimal risk of flooding. Of course, the high grounds nearest the city center were settled first. Eventually that was all filled in leaving, high grounds with a long commute (Rocklin/Roseville/Folsom etc), or areas in a flood plain with a shorter commute (say Natomas).
As for the desirability of the foothills themselves, it isn’t easy to build large swaths of affordable housing in hills. So by definition they tended to have custom homes initially. Thus the foothills appealed to those who could afford a custom home and were willing to live far from the city, and thereby bringing an air of exclusivity to the foothills.
In the last 7 years or so, what has made the foothills more accessible to the masses is better technology. Technology has enabled people like me to “work” without commuting into Sacramento. It has also made it relatively easier to build homes on a larger scale on hillsides. Of course the original “exclusivity” has been seized upon and nurtured by builders for marketing purposes. The newer infrastructure (schools, roads etc) is also very attractive when compared to many of the older parts of Sacramento.
So there you have it. I can’t really come up with any inherent arguments in favor of “hills” versus “valleys”, except perhaps a nice view. Based on observed behavior, valleys seem to win almost every time (until recently). Of course, I prefer the hills to the valley, but if I had to commute to work, a short commute would vastly outweigh any desirability the hills had to offer.
Monday, January 28, 2008
Hitting Home
For some reason it is not as morally challenging to desire inexpensive clothes and other consumer items. Most are made overseas, and I don’t witness the sweatshops, the environmental degradation, and the child labor that results from my purchasing habits.
Real estate on the other hand is very local, and the desire for a reasonably priced housing market is directly affecting several people I know and care for. I believe our local economy has now passed the point of containment (only affecting those directly involved in a transaction). There are many good people out there who are likely to suffer due to the consequences of the housing bust, and the resulting reduction in state and consumer spending. In hindsight some of the decisions by people I know may not have been the best, but I don’t believe that good people “deserve” to have bad things happen to them.
While I am relieved to see that homes are becoming more affordable here in Sacramento, at the same time I am very ashamed of this quest of mine because of the financial ramifications for so many hardworking families. My primary solace is to think in terms of future generations. I would hate to think that my generation, as well as all those that come after me would truly be “priced out forever”.
Of course my sympathies do not extent to anyone on Wall Street whose six and seven figure salaries will be untouched, even though their “innovative financial products” have caused mass hardship. I strongly believe one of the reasons all the experts and pundits didn’t see this coming is because they are so incredibly out of touch with your average American. They had no idea how far people had to stretch to buy a home, how much fraud was occurring by people associated with the REIC, and how people had become dependant on their home equity maintain their lifestyle. No amount of employment, income or consumer sentiment data can really tell this story……Wall Street analysts do not know of the lives behind the Main Street data.
Friday, January 25, 2008
The Waterfalls of El Dorado Hills
My daughter who will be four in March is absolutely taken with all the "waterfalls" around here. She has assigned many of them to our immediate family. For instance, my waterfall is the one at the corner of Silva Vally and Serrano Parkways (the one near the Library). Dad's waterfall, is actually the fountain at the Raley's shopping center. And her little brother's waterfall is the one in front of the Safeway Center off Green Valley.
My daughter gave her waterfall to me after the one at the corner of Latrobe and White Rock was built. But once they built it they rarely turned it on, as they are still completing the buildings. Every day on the way home from daycare she notes whether it is on or not. And I attempt to explain. In the mean time, when hers is off, I am asked to share my waterfall.
The really funny part came when we went to Yosemite this summer. The waterfall you can see from the valley floor wasn't flowing because there was so little water last year....so of course my daughter concluded that the waterfall was turned off. Try explaining that one to a 3.5 year old!
For the Record (RSVP)
So I will buy a drink of choice for the person with the RSVP closest to inventory as well as the person closest to median price (as measured by housing tracker on the week of April 7th). Just to make sure we are all on the same page, as of 1/21/2008 inventory is at 15,190 and median prices is at $324,900.
My guess, inventory at 16,780 and median $317,300.
So please comment/RSVP with your estimate for our get together at Dos in April. Those not coming can still participate but, please indicate that your are not RSVPing.
I will put a link to this posting on the sidebar, in case you want to change your estimate. Estimates recieved after the 30th won't count toward drinks.
Thursday, January 24, 2008
Invitation to a Preemptive Anniversary Smashing
Wanted to put this on your calendar's early, cause if your life is like mine, weekends fill up fast. I tried to find a place that is on the western edge of Folsom so it wouldn't be to far for those in other parts of Sac (but close enough so that Mr. BT can retrieve me if I get a little loopy).
Details:
Where: Dos Coyotes (a Sacramento institution that I dearly missed while living back East) in Folsom right off Folsom Blvd. They serve wine, beer and margaritas and have a great patio.
When: April 13th (the anniversary of Average Buyer blog, 2 days till tax deadlines, and well into the spring "selling season").
What time: 2:30pm till ?
I will try and get a head count later (I think blogger has a polling feature somewhere).
Faltering Food Chain
He seemed pretty knowledgeable about industry trends and news. And had some very interesting rumors to report (which he didn't want spread and I respect that). He knows many of the local builders, so we mainly asked him about which ones are the most reputable.
He's been around for a long time, and seems to think this is one of the worst downturns. If I remember correctly he was thinking mid 2009 for things to start looking up. But I had already had 3 margarita's by then so my memory of this conversation is rather murky =)
The rumor was a pretty juicy one, so I do remember that.....will be sure to report if it pans out.
Wednesday, January 23, 2008
And Now Comes the Lawsuits!
The New York Times ran a story yesterday on a couple in Carlsbad CA that is suing their Realtor.
Sounded like a bit of a shady deal to me, as the Realtor was also the mortgage broker and wouldn't show the couple the appraisal. The Realtor seems to be arguing that the couple should have done more research and due diligence.
I'm a bit confused by the Realtor's argument, isn't it the Realtor's job to help the couple determine if a house is a good buy, and provide them with information to support that claim? I mean, if a Realtor can't do that.....what purpose do they serve?
Of course, I am not saying the couple is faultless, they probably should have used a different broker....and they are squabbling over $100,000 on a $1.2 million home (approximately 8%).
Tuesday, January 22, 2008
What a Difference a Zip Makes
The table below is ranked by the Nominal change since August of 2002. Of course its not always wise to make comparisons based on medians (since its a quirky little stat) and the mix of home in some of these zip codes has changed considerably over the last 6 years.
I was rather surprised at how few zips have escaped the downturn. Only a handful showed drops less than 20% from peak.
Monday, January 21, 2008
December/January Month's Inventory
In Folsom month's inventory took a big jump up, but in EDH it dropped.
Some have postulated that once credit started to thaw that home sales would gain momentum, but I think the momentum is from distressed inventory and not buyers with new credit. I did some checking into this, because EDH sales were actually higher in December compared to November, but distressed sales doubled (short or REO) in El Dorado County in that time (from 20% to 40%). Currently distressed sales now make up 23% of all listings in El Dorado Hills, Cameron Park, and Folsom.
From here on out, I think sales stats are going to be up and down, since last year was so bad.
This month communities are ranked by total sales (from high to low).
Sunday, January 20, 2008
Special Taxes without Special Privileges?
This turned my whole world upside down, since I just assumed my kids will go to the district we are in. Isn't that what the whole, school maps are for? At least it was where I grew up (in California).
So basically people paying the special impact fees for the local school, may not end up enjoying the services they are being asked to pay for! To me this is rather outrageous.
I was not opposed to Mello Roos under most circumstances. It made sense to assess the newer developments for the new roads and schools. But my major assumption was that the people in the new development would be the one who most heavily use the infrastructure the Mello Roos is paying for. Apparently there is no guarantee. With that in mine, I am not nearly as willing to sign up for a home with those additional taxes.
So for all you who have school aged children around here.....if your kids don't get into the local elementary school, are the parents expected to provide transportation to the assigned alternate school? If so EDH, Folsom and CP have just lost a lot of their luster in my eyes.
Friday, January 18, 2008
A Paradoxical Median
For El Dorado, the median resale was down -7.3%, the median new home was down 17.3%, but the total was only down -2.8% (147, 18, and 165 sales repsectively). A weighted average of the two drops would be -8.4%.
I know medians can be a bit wacky to work with, but it still seems odd that both the components show stronger drops than the whole. I'm sure its possible, but if anyone has access to some real data, I would love to see how this happened. I never work with medians in my line of business....so I am not as familiar with their quirks and perterbations.
A Good Start
When professional DINKs (Dual Income No Kids) can afford a home in Sacramento, that is a good start. However I think it will be a little bit longer till its DITO's turn (Dual Income Two Offspring).
The same article noted that previously only 2% of homes were under $200,000, but now 12% are. Using a somewhat generous 3x income estimate.....first time home buyer's will have to have an income of $66,000 and a savings of $40,000 to purchase a home at that amount without overextending themselves. When entry level homes are priced at $150,000 on average, I think we will start seeing some market stabilization.
If future generations are going to be able to afford a home here in California, we need to see additional price drops. Otherwise we will be visiting all of them somewhere in the Midwest.
Thursday, January 17, 2008
The Weekly Screen Scrape - How its Done
As promised, below is a description of the process....I'm sure it's way more detail than desired....and a firsthand look at how crazy obsessive I am.
Each week, around Thursday, I enter my criteria into www.metrolistmls.com I actually have to do two queries since I am looking at two different counties. I use Metrolist, because they show homes that are Pending Sale (a key leading indicator if you ask me). I also use my true price range, not my browsing range (I browse higher to see what is in the pipeline =)
I copy the tables, and paste them into a new Excel file. Then reformat listings into single rows (price, address, city, beds, bath, sqft, and status). If you don’t know Excel very well, this could be really difficult.
I open my Excel screen scrape data file in a separate sheet and paste in the results from above. I compare the new week’s listings to the previous week’s listings using the “match” function on the address field. Once I have old and new listings lined up I can tell what the delta is. Homes that were PS but were not in the new list go onto my “escrow” sheet. Homes that just disappeared go onto my “unsold” sheet. And I also have a “stats” sheet to keep track of weekly totals; since my main list gets updated. I also do a comparison of the prices (using the “if” function), to see if there were price changes (increases are more common than you think).
At first it took quite a while to do this, but I now have it down to 20-30 minutes or so, and that’s only because the listings have increased so much. To look for trends you have to keep the same exact search criteria from week to week.
Basically I look at inventory and Pending Sales ratio. When inventory consistently starts going down and Pending Sales steadily going up….to me that’s a sign the market is finding its equilibrium. Note: This may not be a good indicator if you have a lower limit to your price range, because homes may fall off the bottom.
One additional thing to look for, people withdrawing their listings. To me that’s a sign that there is pent up demand to sell (which no one really talks about, although some become rentals).
Nothing fancy….just very tedious….but it’s not that different from my day job =)
Wednesday, January 16, 2008
Unconventional Thinking: Finding Help
As many observed in an earlier post, a good realtor is worth every penny (or close to it depending on the price of your house). So if you are new to an area, like we essentially were…..how do you go about finding a great realtor?
It’s not easy. Apparently our approach was highly unconventional (and unfortunately it didn’t yield any results).
By January of last year we had three Realtors in mind that we meet by various means: one via a mom’s group I had just joined, one via a recommendation from a recommendation, and another from an open house.
Because our buying experience in D.C. was so bad, we were determined not to make the same mistakes twice (we used a Realtor a friend had used to sell their house). So we decided to interview the agents, instead of wasting their time and ours going to several homes….only to figure out we didn’t really see eye to eye on things. We found out at the interviews that this was incredibly uncommon, and they hadn’t ever really been on an interview to be a buyer’s agent (only sellers). As a side note, we interviewed almost five agents till we found one we liked to sell our house in D.C.
I told all three of them (some brought in their partners) I like numbers and data. Show me samples of the data you can provide. I don’t remember any of them bringing analysis of the local market. They mostly provided local demographic info, most of which is easily found on the internet.
The Interviews:
I mentioned some neighborhoods to try and see how much local information they knew (like about the inadequate wind standards in Stonebriar etc).
We more or less asked the same questions in all three interviews…below are some samples:
---Will they double end a deal? (Mr. BT takes it as a sign that they don’t have the buyers interest truly at heart if they will double end a deal)
---What is their market outlook? (As if in harmony…..they replied, great time to buy …do it now before the market takes off again)
---What did they know of building, construction and architecture? (To find out if they could provide insight on a homes construction or potential problems down the road)
---Given our interests, what neighborhoods would be worth checking out? (To find out if they really listening to us and what we are looking for?)
All three had some local knowledge which was a plus in my book. But in the end, none of them really seemed to offer any insight or factual analysis would lead me to believe their market predictions, let alone want to pay them thousands of dollars to open doors of 10 or so homes. I highly doubt any of them read anything other than what the NAR fed them.
By the time it was all done, I was feeling increasingly uneasy about jumping into the Sacramento market, despite what all the pundits and RE professionals were saying (the rent/buy spread was just too big for comfort). I prayed about what to do. I searched the internet, and lucky for me, I stumbled across Lander and Max’s blogs (which made much more sense, in terms of fundamental economics, than what the “professionals” were saying).
Mr. BT wasn't excited about any of the agents, but he was interested in purchasing sooner than later. Thus we struck the deal that I would closely monitor the market (the weekly screen scrape) to determine if the market really was on its way up again. Eventually I decided to start sharing all the data I was collecting, and thus another bubble blogger was born.
Tuesday, January 15, 2008
Making Apples to Apples Price Comparisons
I believe this is why we are seeing so many home priced “below market” in this Serrano now. Once you include the present value of these additional fees and taxes, the homes are at or slightly above market value.
Below is a quick chart I use help determine the tradeoff between extra fees and home purchase prices. The monthly fee/tax value is on the left, and the present value of those fees/taxes over 30 years is at the intersection with the interest rate. So for example in Serrano, the $296 a month at 6% interest could have bought you around $50,000 more home elsewhere, or adds $50,000 to the home price if you are looking at in Serrano. Of course you do get something for the HOA, like front yard maintenance, so you might want to use a slightly lower figure, but this may be offset by future increases in the HOA.
If you use excel you can estimate this easily using the PV function (but don’t forget to divide the interest rate by 12 or multiply your payments by 12 so that your interest rate and your payments are in the same increment).
Monday, January 14, 2008
Care and Feeding of My Obsession
I have been attempting to keep my obsession in check by limiting my blog habit the local Sacramento sites......but based on several recommendations, I recently started following Calculated Risk. Wow, amazing stuff....CR and Tanta wrap up all my favorite things, economics, housing, tons of data, and current events!
Anyways, are there other gems out there like Calculated Risk that offer insight and analysis? If so let me know (new aggregation doesn't count).